Dr. Marty’s Dog Food: 10 Complaints, Answered With Expert Clarity

Dr. Marty’s dog food is either a miracle meal or a migraine in a bag—depending on who you ask. While the freeze-dried, high-protein formula has never seen a recall and boasts rave reviews from a loyal base, the brand’s darker underbelly includes aggressive marketing tactics, subscription traps, allergic reactions, and more.

---

🔑 Key Takeaways (Quick-Fire Insight)

❓ Complaint	✅ Short Answer
1. Why does my dog throw up after eating Dr. Marty’s?	It’s not a detox—it’s likely food sensitivity.
2. Why is the ordering process so confusing?	Upsell-heavy design intentionally maximizes order size.
3. Why can’t I cancel my subscription?	The system is built to resist quick cancellations.
4. Why did I get charged twice?	Multiple checkout funnels = accidental double orders.
5. Why is the food molding or leaking?	Packaging flaws and humid storage environments.
6. Why is it so expensive?	Ingredients and marketing—not necessarily quantity.
7. Why does customer service ghost me?	Understaffed primary support; better results on public platforms.
8. Why is there pea protein in a meat-based diet?	A cheap way to boost protein analysis numbers.
9. Why did it make my healthy dog sick?	Over-rich formula overwhelming a previously stable gut.
10. Why are the health claims so extreme?	Emotion-based marketing over clinical trial backing.

---

1️⃣ “Why Is My Dog Vomiting After Starting Dr. Marty’s?”

Contrary to popular company explanations, dogs don’t typically vomit due to a “detox” process. In most cases, vomiting is a reaction to a dietary incompatibility—particularly when exposed to multiple novel proteins at once, or a sudden spike in nutrient density.

Digestive Tolerance Table:

🚨 Symptom	⚠️ Common Trigger	🧪 Expert Interpretation
Vomiting	Sudden dietary shift	Too-rich transition
Diarrhea	Multiple proteins + flax/peas	Fiber/protein overload
Bloating	Freeze-dried air volume	Expandable in stomach if not rehydrated

💡 Tip: Always rehydrate freeze-dried food thoroughly before feeding—dry chunks can swell in the gut and cause vomiting or blockages in sensitive dogs.

---

2️⃣ “Why Is The Checkout Page So Pushy and Confusing?”

The brand uses an aggressive funnel-style checkout that mimics infomercial tactics: once you add one product, you’re steered through multiple timed offers, popups, and “wait, don’t leave!” prompts. Many buyers report thinking they bought one bag, only to find 6 charges on their credit card.

Dr. Marty Checkout Funnel Explained 🎯:

🧩 Page Step	⚠️ What Happens	🚫 Risk
Product added to cart	Upsell 1: Extra bag for 20% off	Hidden pre-check
Checkout screen	Auto-enroll subscription box often pre-selected	Recurring charge
Post-purchase	Upsell 2: Add digestive supplement bundle	Order multiplies

🛡️ Expert Tip: Use a browser with pop-up blocking + take a screenshot of your final cart before submitting.

---

3️⃣ “Why Can’t I Cancel My Subscription Easily?”

The auto-renewal system is often opt-in by default and difficult to disengage. Many customers are shocked to discover new shipments arriving 30 days later without clear permission.

Subscription Trap Tactics ⛓️:

🧾 Complaint	🧩 Built-in Obstacle	🧯 Workaround
“I never signed up”	Auto-checked boxes at checkout	Uncheck manually during purchase
“It won’t cancel”	Requires phone call (often long wait)	Use BBB escalation or virtual card blocks
“They still shipped it!”	“It already processed” excuse	Refuse delivery + initiate chargeback if necessary

🧠 Use a virtual card or PayPal with one-time permissions to regain financial control.

---

4️⃣ “Why Did I Get Charged Twice for the Same Order?”

This issue often stems from click confusion inside the upsell funnel, where repeated clicking or unclear redirects can generate two simultaneous orders with different order IDs.

Double Billing Diagnosis 💳:

🔁 Action	💥 Result	🧯 Solution
Refreshed page during checkout	System reloads new offer	Use only one tab, don’t hit “Back” or “Refresh”
Clicked “Claim Discount” multiple times	Creates duplicate baskets	Review email confirmation for extra orders
Didn’t check email summary	Charges unnoticed until bank alert	Monitor account within 24 hrs of order

🛑 Contact bank immediately—disputes for duplicate charges are often easier to win than arguing with the company.

---

5️⃣ “Why Did My Bag Arrive With Mold or Leaking Red Dye?”

Despite the freeze-dried format, complaints of moldy pieces or red leakage have surfaced. The likely culprit: improper storage during shipping or packaging punctures.

Packaging Flaw Table 📦:

🚨 Issue	🔍 Root Cause	🧪 Risk Factor
Mold growth	Heat/humidity exposure before sealing	Moisture inside sealed bag
Red stains/leaks	Beet or cranberry bleed from broken freeze-dried bits	Cosmetic, but concerning if mold follows
Expired appearance	Misread manufacturing vs. expiration date	Dr. Marty date is manufacture date, not expiry

🧼 Always store in an airtight container after opening and keep in a cool, dry place.

---

6️⃣ “Why Is It So Expensive Compared to Other Freeze-Dried Brands?”

You’re paying for premium marketing and multi-protein inclusivity, not necessarily quantity. Dr. Marty’s uses a blend of meats and botanicals, but in relatively small volumes per bag.

Cost Analysis 💰:

🥩 Brand	💵 Price (per lb)	🧾 Notable Feature
Dr. Marty	~$30–$35	Multiple organ meats, branding power
Stella & Chewy’s	~$20–$25	Comparable freeze-dried product
Open Farm RawMix	~$18–$22	Mixed kibble & raw bits

🔍 Per serving, Dr. Marty is nearly 2–3x more expensive, especially for large breed feeding volumes.

---

7️⃣ “Why Is Customer Support Unreachable Until I Go Public?”

There’s a pattern: email and phone support often fail, but BBB and public forum complaints receive swift attention. This implies a reactive support model—resolve complaints only when brand image is at stake.

Customer Service Flow 📞:

📬 Method	⏱️ Response Time	🔄 Resolution Likelihood
Email	48–96 hours	Low, often generic replies
Phone	Long wait / hold drops	Mid, if you reach someone
BBB / TrustPilot	24–48 hrs	High, with full refunds often issued

💡 Document everything and escalate fast—the company has a track record of resolving public complaints quickly.

---

8️⃣ “Why Is Pea Protein in a Meat-Focused Recipe?”

Despite the “meat-first” branding, pea protein is a cheap plant-based additive that inflates the crude protein level in lab tests without providing true meat nutrition. It’s a label game—not a health enhancer.

Protein Source Analysis 🧪:

🔍 Ingredient	🥩 Animal-Based?	📊 Purpose
Turkey, Duck, Beef Liver	✅ Yes	Functional protein + nutrients
Pea Protein	❌ No	Filler to boost crude protein %
Egg or Salmon	✅ Yes	Digestibility + fatty acids

🚫 If your dog is sensitive to legumes, this could trigger reactions despite the meat-first narrative.

---

9️⃣ “Why Did This Make My Healthy Dog Sick?”

Healthy dogs with balanced guts may be overwhelmed by a sudden spike in fats, new proteins, or raw enzymes. This isn’t improvement—it’s intolerance. The nutrient density can disrupt gut flora abruptly.

Gut Shock Symptoms 🚽:

🐶 Dog Type	⚠️ Reaction Type	🧯 Prevention
Healthy kibble-fed	Diarrhea, loose stool	Transition over 10–14 days minimum
Sensitive breeds (Frenchies, Bulldogs)	Gas, itchy ears, paw licking	Use half-portion or as topper
Geriatric dogs	Appetite loss or vomiting	Add digestive enzyme support

💡 Don’t assume all raw-like diets are upgrades—biological compatibility matters more than brand prestige.

---

🔟 “Why Are the Health Claims So Extreme?”

Statements like “will make your dog live longer” or “detoxes your dog’s organs” are not supported by peer-reviewed studies. These claims are based on anecdotal reports and emotion-driven storytelling, not clinical trials.

Claim Validation Table 📊:

🩺 Claim	📚 Backed by Studies?	🔍 Marketing Tactic
“Detoxes your dog”	❌ No vet science supports this	Holistic buzzword
“He’ll live longer”	❌ No lifespan studies exist	Emotional trigger
“Fixes all allergies”	❌ May reduce symptoms, not cure	Overgeneralization

✅ The food is clean and high-quality—but treat miracle claims with skepticism.

---

✅ Final Summary: Expert Snapshot of the 10 Complaints

🚨 Complaint	🎯 Real Reason	🛠️ Suggested Action
Vomiting/Diarrhea	Nutrient shock or food intolerance	Slow transition, vet check
Confusing Checkout	Upsell funnel design	Use screenshots + browser protection
Subscription Trap	Auto-enrollment default	Virtual card or public escalation
Double Charges	Multi-click funnel issue	Review cart + order email
Mold/Leaks	Improper shipping/storage	Contact for replacement ASAP
High Cost	Premium branding, not just ingredients	Use as topper if cost-prohibitive
Ghosted by Support	Understaffed email/phone	Escalate to BBB for fast resolution
Pea Protein Content	Cheap protein inflator	Watch for legume-sensitive dogs
Healthy Dog Reactions	Over-nutrition vs. under-demand	Gradual integration only
Wild Health Claims	No scientific foundation	Evaluate food, not fantasy

---

FAQs 🐾

---

💬 “Why does my dog’s stool turn soft or green after switching to Dr. Marty’s?”

Soft or discolored stools are a frequent issue when introducing a freeze-dried raw diet, especially one as protein-dense and plant-rich as Dr. Marty’s. The sudden influx of unfamiliar organ meats, cruciferous vegetables (like kale and broccoli), and flaxseed can stimulate bile release and alter stool composition—sometimes drastically.

💩 Stool Change	🧪 Possible Ingredient Cause	💡 Expert Strategy
Greenish hue	Kale, broccoli, bile shift	Introduce gradually over 10+ days
Loose/Soft	Organ meats, salmon oil, pumpkin	Mix with boiled rice for 3–5 days
Mucus-covered	Digestive inflammation from new proteins	Stop feeding for 48 hours, then retry slower

Key Insight: “Detox” is a misleading term. This is more often gut biome turbulence, not cleansing.

---

💬 “Why is it so difficult to find unbiased reviews of Dr. Marty’s food?”

That’s because much of the online visibility is dominated by affiliate marketing, where reviewers earn commissions through links. These pieces tend to overemphasize benefits while minimizing or omitting customer service criticisms or adverse reactions.

🌐 Source Type	🔎 Bias Risk	🛡️ Reader Protection
Affiliate blog (“Top 5 Dog Foods”)	⚠️ High (commission-influenced)	Use ad blockers to strip affiliate links
Amazon/Walmart verified reviews	✅ Moderate	Sort by “Most Recent” for trend accuracy
Vet-authored platforms (Tufts, WSAVA)	✅ Low	Favor peer-reviewed vet sources over opinion

Best Practice: Cross-reference claims with independent veterinary publications or consumer forums like DogFoodAdvisor forums or Reddit’s r/dogs for balanced narratives.

---

💬 “Can I trust the ingredient label on Dr. Marty’s if it includes ‘pea protein’?”

Yes, but interpret with caution. The term “pea protein” is legally allowed on labels, but it inflates protein content on the guaranteed analysis without contributing the same amino acid richness as meat-based proteins. This is known as “protein spiking”.

⚖️ Ingredient	🧬 Contribution to Amino Profile	🥩 Meat Equivalency
Turkey, Duck, Beef	Complete amino acid profile	✅ High bioavailability
Pea Protein	Lacks methionine & cysteine	❌ Lower biological value
Egg or Fish	High-quality supplemental proteins	✅ Excellent digestibility

Expert Note: Pea protein is not dangerous, but it shouldn’t be a primary source. It’s a protein filler, not a true replacement.

---

💬 “Is it safe to feed Dr. Marty’s to a puppy or senior dog?”

Dr. Marty’s formulas are not universally tailored. While some versions like “Healthy Growth” are aimed at puppies, the high protein and fat levels in the adult versions may overload a puppy’s kidneys or be too rich for a sedentary senior with lower energy demands.

🐕 Life Stage	🥗 Formula Suitability	⚖️ Nutrient Risk
Puppy (under 12 mo)	“Healthy Growth” only	Calcium/phosphorus imbalance risk in adult formula
Adult (1–7 years)	“Essential Wellness” ideal	Generally suitable
Senior (8+ years)	May be too protein-heavy	Watch for weight gain or lethargy

Pro Tip: Monitor hydration and switch to hydrated feeding to support digestion, especially for aging dogs.

---

💬 “Why doesn’t Dr. Marty offer kibble or a canned version for convenience?”

Dr. Marty’s branding is rooted in raw ancestral nutrition, which fundamentally opposes the extrusion and high-heat processes that define kibble and canned food manufacturing. Their positioning hinges on being anti-kibble—not just nutritionally, but philosophically.

🥫 Format	⏳ Shelf Stability	🔬 Nutrient Retention
Freeze-dried	✅ 24+ months (if unopened)	✅ Excellent (low-heat process)
Kibble	✅ Up to 12 months	❌ High nutrient loss from extrusion
Canned	✅ High moisture, ~2 years	⚠️ Moderate nutrient degradation

Important: Freeze-dried foods like Dr. Marty’s bridge the gap between raw and kibble, but require more effort (hydration, portion control) and carry higher per-meal cost.

---

💬 “Can I feed this exclusively, or should I combine it with another food?”

Exclusivity is only safe if the product meets AAFCO standards for “complete and balanced” nutrition. While Dr. Marty’s states this claim, using it exclusively may be cost-prohibitive or overly rich for dogs accustomed to simpler diets.

🍽️ Feeding Strategy	💰 Budget Impact	🦴 Digestive Adaptability
100% Dr. Marty’s	🚨 Expensive (~$5–10/day for large dogs)	Risk of GI upset if not eased in
50/50 Mix with kibble	✅ Moderates cost, adds palatability	Ideal for picky eaters
Topper use only	💡 Enhances nutrient variety	Safest for transition

Bottom Line: Most owners have long-term success using it as a topper, not as a standalone food source.

---

💬 “Why do they advertise on YouTube with scare tactics?”

Dr. Marty’s marketing relies on contrast-based persuasion—highlighting the perceived dangers of common pet foods (corn, by-products, preservatives) to create emotional urgency. It’s effective but often lacks context or nuance.

📺 Ad Tactic	🎯 Emotional Trigger	🔍 Scientific Backing
“Dog Destroyers” visuals	Fear of harm from fillers	❌ Generalized, lacks specifics
Testimonial montage	Hope, transformation	✅ Based on real cases but not clinical trials
“Vets won’t tell you this”	Anti-establishment bias	❌ Discredits mainstream vet science

Tip: Balance emotionally charged ads with objective sources before making health decisions.

---

💬 “Why does the bag seem half-empty when it arrives?”

Freeze-dried food is incredibly light and dense in nutrients, meaning a 1 lb bag may feed a small dog for over a week. It’s the air content and moisture removal that makes the packaging look deceptive—but it’s not a scam.

📦 Bag Size	🧪 Actual Contents	🐶 Servings (Small Dog)
16 oz (1 lb)	100% freeze-dried food	~7–10 meals when hydrated
6 lb bulk bag	6x volume when rehydrated	~1 month for 25-lb dog

Clarification: Hydration expands the food significantly—what looks “half-full” is actually volume-optimized for safety and shelf life.

---

💬 “Why is the product never on sale?”

Dr. Marty’s pricing strategy avoids widespread discounting to maintain a luxury-tier brand image and avoid undercutting affiliate sales partners. Promotions exist, but they’re targeted, time-limited, and often linked to subscription enrollment.

🎯 Promotion Type	📉 Discount Value	🧯 Catch
First-time buyer offer	20–30% off	Auto-enrolls subscription
Multi-bag bundle	Up to 25%	Higher upfront cost
“VIP” email subscriber	Seasonal 10–15%	Infrequent and exclusive

Expert Move: Create a burner email, subscribe for one-time offer, then unsubscribe and buy from 3rd-party retailers like Pet Supplies Plus or Walmart at stable pricing.

---

💬 “Can this help with allergies or itching?”

Yes—and no. Dr. Marty’s ingredient list excludes common allergens (wheat, corn, soy), and its formulas rich in omega-3s, flaxseed, and organ meats can support skin repair. However, the inclusion of novel proteins like duck and salmon could trigger new allergies in already sensitive dogs.

🐾 Condition	🧪 Dr. Marty’s Benefit	⚠️ Potential Issue
Environmental allergies	✅ Omega-3s reduce inflammation	❌ Doesn’t fix external triggers
Food sensitivities (chicken, beef)	✅ “Sensitivity Select” avoids major allergens	✅ Safer alternative
Chronic ear/skin issues	✅ May reduce flare-ups	⚠️ If no improvement, allergen could still be present

Veterinary Insight: Always conduct an elimination trial with hydrolyzed protein first, then consider rich formulas like Dr. Marty’s if results are inconclusive.

---

💬 “Can Dr. Marty’s cause long-term nutritional imbalances if used daily?”

Only if used improperly or in isolation. While Dr. Marty’s food is advertised as “complete and balanced,” its nutrient density can cause overconsumption of certain elements — like fat-soluble vitamins — if not portioned precisely. Moreover, dogs with unique metabolic conditions (e.g., liver shunts, pancreatitis, or early kidney disease) may not tolerate this richness well.

⚖️ Nutrient Risk	🧬 Cause	🧩 Long-Term Concern
Excess Vitamin A	Liver-heavy formulas	Joint calcification, liver stress
Elevated Fat Intake	High duck/salmon content	Weight gain, pancreatitis in predisposed dogs
Phosphorus Load	Organ meats	Risk for dogs with renal compromise

Vet Advisory: Routine bloodwork is advised every 6–12 months for dogs on dense, premium diets to monitor liver and kidney function, even if no symptoms appear.

---

💬 “Why is my dog drinking less water since switching to Dr. Marty’s?”

This is a hydration illusion. When served dry, freeze-dried food is ultra-concentrated, requiring moisture from the body to aid digestion. As a result, dogs often feel thirstier — but some don’t drink enough to compensate. However, if rehydrated, Dr. Marty’s can provide a moisture boost, often resulting in less need for voluntary water intake.

💧 Water Source	🌡️ Result	🐶 Owner Tip
Dry-fed	Internal dehydration risk	Rehydrate with warm water or low-sodium broth
Hydrated servings	Balanced fluid intake	Observe urination frequency for signs
Wet topper mix	Supports bladder and kidney health	Mix with canned food for picky eaters

Insight: A hydrated gut digests protein better. Without moisture, your dog is relying on internal reserves — which isn’t ideal long term.

---

💬 “Why is the food so crumbly and powdery at the bottom of the bag?”

This occurs due to the fragility of freeze-dried meats and vegetables. Unlike kibble, which is coated in fats and binders, Dr. Marty’s is fragile by design. High-protein components like liver or heart flake easily when jostled during transit.

📦 Crumble Cause	🔍 Explanation	🛠️ Solution
Lightweight freeze-dried ingredients	Fragile texture	Use crumbs as a topper or mix with yogurt
No binding agents	No cornmeal or starch to preserve shape	Store bag upright, don’t shake
Pressure from shipping	Vibration during transport	Order locally to minimize transit time

Bonus Tip: Some users blend leftover crumbs with bone broth or into frozen treats — no waste, added enrichment.

---

💬 “Is Dr. Marty’s suitable for diabetic dogs?”

This is not a one-size-fits-all answer. While Dr. Marty’s is relatively low in carbohydrates compared to kibble, it still includes fruit-based sugars (apple, blueberry, cranberry) and sweet potato, which may spike blood glucose in sensitive dogs.

🍠 Ingredient	📊 Glycemic Risk	💉 Impact on Diabetics
Sweet Potato	Moderate-high	Slow glucose rise, but still carbs
Apple & Cranberry	Natural sugar	Risk of postprandial spikes
Pumpkin Seeds	Low impact	Safe fiber and fat source

Veterinary Caution: For diabetic dogs, feed precise portions, test blood glucose post-meal, and avoid treats with any sugar-dense additions. Dr. Marty’s “Sensitivity Select” has slightly fewer carb sources and may be safer when fed with monitoring.

---

💬 “Why is my dog’s breath worse after eating this food?”

Increased odor often comes from a higher sulfur load in organ meats and possible microbial shifts in the mouth and gut. Proteins like liver, heart, and tripe contain sulfur-containing amino acids, which produce hydrogen sulfide — the classic “rotten egg” smell.

🐽 Cause	🔬 Mechanism	🧼 Solution
Organ-rich formula	Higher sulfur breakdown	Add dental chews or raw carrots
Protein fermentation	Gut flora change	Introduce probiotics gradually
Food sticking to teeth	Freeze-dried texture leaves residue	Brush or use water additive daily

Expert Trick: Add parsley, spirulina, or chlorophyll tablets (vet-approved) to neutralize odor-producing compounds naturally.

---

💬 “Can I mix Dr. Marty’s with a veterinary prescription diet?”

Yes—but with caution. Prescription diets are carefully calibrated for medical conditions. Adding Dr. Marty’s may disrupt mineral balances, calorie density, or protein limits. However, some vets allow small topper portions for flavor enhancement or to entice picky eaters.

🥘 Prescription Diet	⚠️ Risk When Mixed	✅ Safe Use Scenario
Renal support (e.g., Hill’s k/d)	Excess protein/phosphorus	5–10% of meal as topper only
Low-fat GI formula (e.g., i/d)	High fat in duck/liver	Use leaner Dr. Marty’s blend (e.g., turkey-based)
Hypoallergenic (e.g., z/d)	Allergen introduction	Avoid unless allergy profile known

Golden Rule: Always ask your vet before mixing — especially when dealing with kidney, liver, or pancreatitis-prone patients.

---

💬 “Why does the food smell so strong?”

That intense aroma comes from the absence of masking agents and the presence of concentrated organ meats and freeze-dried fish. Unlike kibble, which is often deodorized during extrusion, raw-based foods retain volatile compounds — including taurine-rich tissues and omega oils.

👃 Odor Source	⚗️ Sensory Profile	🐕 Dog Reaction
Salmon & Pollock oil	Briny, pungent	High palatability
Liver & heart	Metallic, iron-rich	Triggers natural hunting instincts
Dried kale & broccoli	Sulfuric undertone	Some dogs avoid initially

Pro Tip: Store opened bags inside airtight containers to reduce odor transfer and slow fat oxidation.

---

💬 “Why does my dog seem hungrier even though I feed the same calories?”

This could be due to the difference in food volume and satiety signaling. Freeze-dried food shrinks during dehydration, so it may look like less food in the bowl—tricking both owner and dog. Also, high-protein diets metabolize differently, sometimes leaving less residual bulk in the stomach, especially without enough fiber.

🍽️ Satiety Factor	🔍 Explanation	🛠️ Adjustments
Low volume meals	Freeze-dried food is calorie-dense	Hydrate fully before serving
Low fermentable fiber	Less bulk triggers fewer gut signals	Add cooked pumpkin or green beans
High metabolic response	Proteins digest faster than carbs	Feed more frequently (3x/day)

Expert Insight: Hunger cues aren’t always nutritional needs — often they’re texture- or ritual-based behaviors. Hydrated food stretches volume without calorie inflation.

---

💬 “Why does my dog eat less but still gain weight on Dr. Marty’s?”

Caloric density is the hidden culprit. Because Dr. Marty’s is freeze-dried, a small volume contains significantly more calories per ounce than traditional kibble. When fed in equal portions by volume instead of weight, dogs often consume 30–50% more calories than intended.

🍽️ Meal Volume	🔥 Calorie Concentration	⚠️ Risk
1 cup of kibble	~350 kcal	🐶 Normal portion
1 cup Dr. Marty’s (dry)	~500–600 kcal	⚠️ Overfeeding danger
1 cup rehydrated	~180–220 kcal (varies by water ratio)	✅ Better control

Pro Tip: Always measure by weight, not by scoops. Use a digital food scale, and refer to the calorie content per ounce listed on the bag. Overweight dogs can face joint strain, endocrine disruption, and reduced lifespan even if eating “clean.”

---

💬 “Why is there a strong fish smell in the ‘Essential Wellness’ formula even when it’s not fish-based?”

That’s due to the inclusion of salmon oil and fish liver as secondary ingredients, used for their EPA/DHA content and skin/coat benefits. Despite turkey and beef being the primary proteins, even trace amounts of fish oils carry strong olfactory signatures — especially when freeze-dried without masking agents.

🐟 Source	🧪 Purpose	👃 Intensity Level
Salmon oil	Omega-3 fatty acids	🐾 Moderate to strong
Fish liver	Vitamin D, A, fatty acids	🐟 Very strong
Mixed animal oils	Palatability enhancer	🐶 Mild

Note: Dogs are more tolerant of these odors than humans — strong fish notes often enhance palatability. If your dog has a fish sensitivity, check the full ingredient list, not just the headline protein.

---

💬 “Why does my dog’s coat look greasy or waxy after switching?”

That usually signals an omega-3 surplus or imbalance in essential fatty acids. Dr. Marty’s is rich in flaxseed, fish oil, and sunflower seed oil—excellent for shine, but in excess, these can cause sebaceous overactivity or build-up on the coat.

🐕 Skin Change	🔍 Nutritional Cause	🧴 What to Do
Greasy, waxy coat	Omega-6/Omega-3 imbalance	Skip additional supplements
Dandruff-like flakes	Sudden fat metabolism change	Add small amounts of zinc or biotin
Soft, oily stools	Excess unsaturated fat	Cut portion size by 10–15%

Vet Insight: Balance is key. If you’re already giving fish oil capsules or fatty treats, discontinue them when feeding Dr. Marty’s — the food likely supplies more than enough.

---

💬 “Is it safe to give this food to a dog with pancreatitis history?”

Not recommended without strict veterinary supervision. Pancreatitis-prone dogs typically need low-fat, easily digestible diets, and many Dr. Marty’s formulas exceed the safe threshold of 10–12% fat (dry matter basis). Some versions climb into 27% fat, which can provoke flare-ups.

⚠️ Ingredient	🔥 Fat Content	🧬 Pancreatic Load
Duck, salmon, organ meats	High	❌ Avoid
Turkey-based only	Moderate	⚠️ Only in small topper portions
Skinless white meats (boiled)	Low	✅ Best for management

Critical Note: Pancreatitis is not just about fat—it’s about fat type and load per meal. Break meals into 3–4 daily servings if you’re experimenting, and stop immediately at first sign of vomiting or lethargy.

---

💬 “Why does the food change color or texture from one bag to the next?”

This is typical in non-extruded, minimally processed foods. Because Dr. Marty’s uses real whole meats and seasonal vegetables, natural variance in meat fat content, harvest timing, and even freeze-drying duration affects final appearance.

🎨 Visual Change	🔍 Explanation	✅ Is It Safe?
Lighter or darker pellets	Batch-to-batch turkey/beef blend	✅ Yes
Slight oiliness or dust	Natural meat oils rising to surface	✅ Yes
Occasional green specks	Dried spinach or kale bits	✅ Yes

Manufacturing Tip: Color variance in raw-style food is a sign of minimal standardization—not poor quality. However, if the food is damp, moldy, or smells fermented, contact the brand immediately.

---

💬 “What happens if I stop feeding Dr. Marty’s suddenly?”

Switching away cold turkey can shock the gut microbiome—especially if your dog has been on Dr. Marty’s for several months. These foods support different bacterial colonies than kibble, so going back to processed options may cause loose stools, poor appetite, or gassiness.

🔄 Transition Direction	🧪 Gut Response	🛠️ Best Strategy
Kibble ➝ Dr. Marty’s	Possible die-off, loose stool	10-day gradual mix-in
Dr. Marty’s ➝ Kibble	Microbial disruption, hunger	Reintroduce old food slowly, mix 50/50
Dr. Marty’s ➝ Fresh cooked	Less shock, softer stool	Hydrate well, add prebiotics

Expert Tip: Introduce a daily probiotic or fermented food (like kefir or goat milk) during any switch to protect gut flora.

---

💬 “Why are returns so complicated even with a money-back guarantee?”

It’s rooted in operational friction, not refund resistance. Dr. Marty’s requires the customer to pay for return shipping, and often necessitates phone calls instead of online cancellations. Their guarantee is real, but it’s framed around a retention-first model, which slows down refunds.

📦 Return Hurdle	⛓️ Business Reason	🛠️ Workaround
No online cancel portal	Phone contact builds rapport	Request email confirmation of cancellation
Return shipping paid by customer	Discourages non-serious buyers	Use a tracked service and save receipt
Delay in refunds	Internal review needed	Escalate to BBB for fast resolution if ignored

Pro Move: Use virtual cards (like Privacy.com or Apple Pay single-use) when ordering. If there’s a dispute, you can freeze charges instantly.

---

💬 “Can I use Dr. Marty’s as a long-term topper without losing nutritional balance?”

Absolutely — and it’s one of the most efficient ways to leverage the brand’s quality without overspending. Used as a topper (15–25% of the daily meal), it enhances flavor, introduces organ meats, and boosts micronutrient variety with less risk of fat overload.

🍲 Usage Style	💰 Cost Efficiency	🧬 Nutrient Variety
Full meal	High ($3–8 per day)	✅ Complete profile
50/50 mix with base kibble	Moderate	✅ Great blend of textures
25% topper	Very low cost	✅ Still benefits from oils, organ meats

Tip for Toy Breeds: Since caloric needs are lower, you can stretch a single bag 2–3x longer by topping over grain-free wet food or air-dried meat bases.